Get your scream on

The scoop on four fine creameries as things heat up

Allyson Reedy

Special to Metromix
May 14, 2008

Get your scream on
Gelazzi whips up some goodness (Credit: McBoat Photography)

According to Henry James, the two most beautiful words in the English language are ‘summer afternoon.’ I agree, but would like to add ‘Summer afternoon with ice cream in hand while watching hot, buff men playing Frisbee in the park. Shirtless. Oh, and I look about 10 pounds thinner.’ Yeah, the romance languages ain’t got nothing on us.

I saw a poll that said a majority of women prefer ice cream to sex. Really brings new meaning to “I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream,” huh? No matter who’s doing the screaming, ice cream is damn good, and ‘tis the season to enjoy it in all its creamy, refreshing glory. Luckily for us, the Denver area has got lots of options to get our ‘scream on.

Glacier Homemade Ice Cream
Glacier is the Tiger Woods of ice cream; the Ron Jeremy, the Chuck Norris. It’s just the best there is and it kicks – or penetrates – the competition’s ass. Like many other ice cream parlors, they make all of their 800 flavors of ice cream in-house. But the TLC doesn’t stop there – they also concoct their own hot fudge, gelato and chocolate mix-ins. Stores typically have 80 flavors on-hand at a time, enough to send one of those annoying lactose-intolerants to their grave. But my God would they die happy! Try the Death by Chocolate, White Chocolate Wally Biscotti 3D Fudge and Peanut Butter Blast.

Bonnie Brae Ice Cream
Bonnie Brae is what you imagine an ice cream shop looked like before the likes of Dairy Queen and Cold Stone infiltrated the market.  Its adorable red and white motif and candy-striper-esque uniforms for its employees are so 1950s style that you’ll be cursing those damn Soviets for winning the space race instead of praising them for breeding hot tennis players. They make all your fave warm-weather treats, from malts to sundaes to Italian sodas.  But nothing says bliss quite like an ice cream cone.  One scoop Oreos and Cream, one scoop Amaretto Peach and you’ll be on your way to summertime ecstasy. 

CJ’s Frozen Custard
If variety is the spice of life, than the frozen custard at CJ’s is spiced just about as well as the menu at Taco Bell. With only three flavors – vanilla, chocolate and flavor of the day – CJ’s doesn’t exactly give you a lot of choices, but what they do offer is pretty damn delicious. The White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, with real nuts mixed in, tasted like I was eating a frozi-fied Mrs. Fields cookie. Unfortunately the atmosphere of this place is reminiscent of a preschool. With ice cream cones painted around the perimeter, tables and chairs designed for hobbits and enough high chairs lined up to accommodate Brangelina’s brood, you could feel like a kid again. But then again, that isn’t so bad.

Gelazzi
I’m not sure what it takes to get a Nobel Prize these days, but I’m thinking that whoever came up with the idea to combine ice cream with liquor deserves one. At Gelazzi you get more than just 32 flavors (take that Baskin Robbins!) of homemade gelato, you also get a buzz off of their Gelatinis. A mixture of gelato and liqueurs, the Gelatinis will have milkshakes going to therapy for inadequacy issues. The trendy Larimer Square locale and high prices will make you feel like you’re at one of those classy bars, but with twice the calories!